Skip to content
BenmoreConstruction Group · New Haven, CT(203) 791-3999Answered 24/7
Roof FAQ

Synthetic slate or real slate: which fits your house?

An honest comparison of composite and natural slate for New Haven area homes: weight, lifespan, look, cost and when each one makes sense.

MTMaude Throckmorton, Slate & Roofing Editor
Composite synthetic slate tiles in a gray and purple blend being installed on a steep Colonial roof

The quick comparison

  • Real slate: heaviest, longest lasting, most expensive up front.
  • Synthetic slate: light, easier to install and repair, lasts about half as long as hard slate.

Weight and framing

Natural slate weighs roughly three to four times as much as asphalt shingles. Houses that were built for slate can carry it. A house that has had asphalt for decades may need its framing checked before going back to stone. Composite slate weighs about the same as a heavy architectural shingle, so framing is rarely an issue.

Pallet of natural Vermont roofing slate beside a ladder at a historic house job site

Lifespan

Hard Vermont and New York slate commonly lasts 100 years or more. Most composite slate products carry 50-year limited warranties. Over a century, real slate can cost less per year, but only if you plan to keep the house or value that for the next owner.

Look

From the street, good composite slate in a blended color reads as slate. Up close, real slate has a cleft texture and natural color variation that synthetics imitate but do not match exactly. In historic districts, the commission may expect real slate on visible slopes.

Cost

On a typical New Haven house, composite slate runs from the mid $20,000s to the low $50,000s, and natural slate from the high $30,000s up. See our roof repair prices for current ranges.

What we recommend

Keep and repair real slate when it is sound. Reslate when the house and budget call for it. Choose synthetic when real slate is out of reach and you want the look without asphalt.

Questions about your own roof? Call (203) 791-3999 any hour and a person will answer.

More answers

Keep reading

Is my slate roof worth saving?

How to tell whether an old New Haven slate roof needs repairs or replacing: slate type, nail failure, flashing and what each choice costs.

A leak, a slipped slate or a storm-torn roof?

Call any hour. A person at our New Haven office picks up, asks what you are seeing and books a crew.

Call (203) 791-3999
Call (203) 791-3999, answered 24/7