Skip to content
BenmoreConstruction Group · New Haven, CT(203) 791-3999Answered 24/7
Roof FAQ

Is my slate roof worth saving?

How to tell whether an old New Haven slate roof needs repairs or replacing: slate type, nail failure, flashing and what each choice costs.

MTMaude Throckmorton, Slate & Roofing Editor
Close view of a weathered gray-green slate roof with copper flashing on a Victorian house in Connecticut

The short answer

Most slate roofs around New Haven are worth saving. Hard slate from Vermont and New York often lasts well past 100 years, and what usually fails first is the metal around it: nails, flashing and gutters. A roof that leaks is not the same as a roof that is worn out.

Start with the slate itself

Look at a few slates up close, from a ladder or with binoculars. Healthy slate is hard, has crisp edges and rings when tapped. Worn slate flakes in layers, turns soft and powdery at the surface or breaks when it is handled. If most slates look healthy, the roof is a repair job.

The type of slate matters too. Vermont unfading green and gray-black slates from New York are known for long life. Some softer Pennsylvania slates were made to last around 60 to 90 years, so a roof of those may be near its end even if it looks fine from the street.

Roofer using a slate ripper to remove a broken slate on a steep roof, safety harness and hook ladder

Watch for nail sickness

When slates slide out in groups, often in a line, the nails holding them have rusted through. That is called nail sickness. A few slipped slates can be put back with copper slate hooks. When it is happening across whole slopes, the slate can be stripped, sorted and relaid on new copper nails, which keeps the old slate and replaces only what failed.

Flashing and gutters come next

Many slate roofs leak at chimneys, valleys and walls because the original tin or lead flashing has worn out, or because someone covered it with tar. Replacing that flashing in copper fixes the leak and lets the slate keep going. Built-in gutters behind the cornice are the other big source of trouble on these houses.

Repair, relay or replace

  • Repair when a few slates are broken or missing. Typical cost: a few hundred to about $3,000.
  • Strip and relay when the slate is sound but nails or underlayment have failed. Typical cost: often half or less of a new slate roof.
  • Replace when the slate is soft or flaking across the roof. New slate on a whole house usually runs from the high $30,000s up.

Our slate roof check walks through these questions in a minute and points you to the right next step.

Do not let anyone walk all over it

A slate roof can be damaged by the people sent to fix it. Ask how the roofer will get on the roof. The answer should involve roof brackets, hook ladders or a lift, not walking straight on the slate.

Questions about your own roof? Call (203) 791-3999 any hour and a person will answer.

More answers

Keep reading

A leak, a slipped slate or a storm-torn roof?

Call any hour. A person at our New Haven office picks up, asks what you are seeing and books a crew.

Call (203) 791-3999
Call (203) 791-3999, answered 24/7