Synthetic slate or real slate: which fits your house?
An honest comparison of composite and natural slate for New Haven area homes: weight, lifespan, look, cost and when each one makes sense.
A plain comparison of the three flat roof systems we install on New Haven multi-family houses, with costs, lifespans and when each fits.

Most three-families built in New Haven between about 1890 and 1930 have a low-slope main roof behind a small front gable or cornice. That kept costs down and allowed full-height rooms on the top floor. It also means the main roof is one of the most important things to get right on these buildings.
EPDM is black synthetic rubber, installed in large sheets with few seams. It handles freeze and thaw well and is easy to repair years later. It absorbs heat in summer, so top-floor units can run warm. Expect 20 to 30 years from a good installation.

TPO is a white membrane with seams welded by hot air, which makes them very strong. The white surface reflects sun and keeps the top floor cooler. Repairs on old TPO can be harder than on EPDM. Expect a similar lifespan.
Modified bitumen is an asphalt-based sheet, usually in two layers, with a granulated top. It is the toughest of the three under foot traffic, so it suits roofs with decks, equipment or regular access. We install torch-free versions on occupied buildings.
Drainage. Water that sits on a flat roof for days finds every weak seam. Tapered insulation, crickets behind chimneys and properly sized scuppers matter more than which membrane you choose. So does the joint where the flat roof meets the front gable and porch roofs, which is the leak we fix most on these houses.
For a typical three-family main roof in New Haven, a full tear-off and new membrane usually falls between about $6,800 and $19,400, depending on size, insulation and how many pipes, hatches and chimneys pass through it. See our roof repair prices for more ranges.
Questions about your own roof? Call (203) 791-3999 any hour and a person will answer.
More answers
An honest comparison of composite and natural slate for New Haven area homes: weight, lifespan, look, cost and when each one makes sense.
Why the roof under solar panels matters, when to reroof before installing solar, and how panel removal and reinstall works when the roof wears out first.
How to size gutters and downspouts for steep, older New Haven roofs, why 5 inch gutters often overflow, and where to put the downspouts.
Call any hour. A person at our New Haven office picks up, asks what you are seeing and books a crew.