Skip to content
BenmoreConstruction Group · New Haven, CT(203) 791-3999Answered 24/7
Roof FAQ

Box gutters on old houses: reline or replace?

How built-in box gutters work on older Connecticut houses, why they fail, and when relining beats converting to hanging gutters.

MTMaude Throckmorton, Slate & Roofing Editor
Ornate wood cornice with a built-in box gutter on a Victorian house, paint peeling below

What a box gutter is

A box gutter is built into the roof edge or the cornice instead of hanging off the fascia. They were common on Victorians and Colonial Revivals, and you can tell you have them if there is no visible gutter but there are downspouts.

Why they fail

The original lining was tin or copper, and over a century the tin rusts, the solder cracks and layers of tar trap water. Because the gutter sits inside the wood, a leak rots the cornice from the inside long before you see it.

New soldered copper lining inside a box gutter on an old house roof edge

Relining

Relining keeps the look of the house. We strip the old lining, rebuild rotted wood and install soldered copper or a modern membrane. Copper lasts the longest. Membrane costs less. Most relining jobs run between about $2,850 and $11,400.

Converting to hanging gutters

On some houses, the box gutter can be roofed over and a hanging gutter added. It costs less, but it changes the look and may not be allowed on historic houses. On houses with deep cornices, it often looks wrong.

Our advice

If the house has historic value or a deep cornice, reline. If the gutters are small, shallow and the house is not historic, conversion can make sense. We price both when either fits.

Questions about your own roof? Call (203) 791-3999 any hour and a person will answer.

More answers

Keep reading

A leak, a slipped slate or a storm-torn roof?

Call any hour. A person at our New Haven office picks up, asks what you are seeing and books a crew.

Call (203) 791-3999
Call (203) 791-3999, answered 24/7